Log In
Register
11:46 am
Gold
June 30, 2017
Offline
Feed field named "entry_id" in HTTP API responses is not a true ID.
It is merely a counter, because it resets every time a channel is cleared.
Problems:
1. As counters, these are almost useless since they are not unique and can't be used for addressing.
2. If they can't be used then why ThingSpeak exposes them at all?
Suggestions:
1. Make them true IDs and provide tools for using them.
2. Drop them from ThingSpeak API altogether to avoid confusion.
12:00 pm
MathWorks
May 1, 2016
Offline
Thank you for your suggestions. The ThingSpeak team has thought about these and many, many more over years of running the service.
The entry_id exists for historical reasons. For what it is worth, we have a number of users who rely on it. Removing this entirely will impact existing users who need to reprogram their devices that may be deployed remotely.
We recommend that users do not use the entry_id field. However, at this time we do not see a solution to eliminate it without causing our users pain.
Like I mentioned in your other thread - data stored on ThingSpeak is time series data. At this time we believe the appropriate way to index it is using the start and end time.
2:01 pm
Gold
June 30, 2017
Offline
Hello, Vinod
It is definitely a good reason to retain this field.
Why don't you make it a "true" ID then and avoid further confusion?
I see many cases where timestamps are not adequate and
true IDs would be helpful.
One such example I already mentioned in my other post
about incremental data processing.
Regards
9:52 am
Gold
June 30, 2017
Offline
What takes you so long to respond?
10:06 am
Admin
January 18, 2011
Offline
We will consider having a true id for the data. Right now, the combination of channel#+entry_id is unique. Thanks.
1:34 pm
Gold
June 30, 2017
Offline
Hans said
Right now, the combination of channel#+entry_id is unique. Thanks.
I disagree:
heh said
Feed field named "entry_id" in HTTP API responses is not a true ID.
It is merely a counter, because it resets every time a channel is cleared.
Why don't you try it yourself?
Regards
2:13 pm
Admin
January 18, 2011
Offline
Of course. If you reset the channel, you reset the entry ID. If you need to identify points with a GUID or a global unique identifier, other users use the status field. Then, use status=true when you read the data.
Most Users Ever Online: 166
Currently Online:
23 Guest(s)
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
rw950431: 272
Vinod: 240
piajola: 95
turgo: 70
vespapierre: 63
Adarsh_Murthy: 62
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 1
Members: 8665
Moderators: 1
Admins: 2
Forum Stats:
Groups: 3
Forums: 14
Topics: 1600
Posts: 5760
Newest Members:
Sahil Nair, ahancity, samexpert, Senseworks, h-kasiri, kleifimmaklyModerators: cstapels: 460
Administrators: Hans: 405, lee: 457
